FB Pixel

To Photograph in B&W or Convert in Post? The Great Debate!

Couple embraces on urban sidewalk, black and white photo.

The age-old question that plagues photographers everywhere: to shoot in black and white or to convert later in post? It’s like asking whether pineapple belongs on pizza. Everyone has an opinion! But let’s dive into this deliciously complex topic with a sprinkle of wit and a side of enthusiasm.

First off, here’s the RAW, unfiltered truth: I don’t know! Not quite the answer you were hoping for, huh? But let’s be real. When it comes to art, using words like “should,” “never,” or “better” feels like trying to fit a square peg into a round hole. Every artist has their own unique lens (pun absolutely intended!) through which they see the world.

Now, don’t dismiss shooting B&W in-camera just yet! For many photographers, it’s the golden ticket to unlocking their creative genius. If you’ve ever dabbled in the world of black and white film, you’ll know the thrill of transforming a technicolor world into monochrome magic. Back in the day, you had to be a wizard at visualizing how vibrant hues would translate into shadows and highlights, without the luxury of instant feedback.

Man sitting on chair under tree in park

Picture this: you’ve loaded your camera with a roll of B&W film, and now you’re left to your own devices for the next 24 frames. You had to master the art of seeing in tones rather than colors, and you probably got cozy with a few color filters along the way, because why not jazz things up a bit? Remember that red filter that made skin tones pop and skies deep blue? Good times!

Fast forward to today, where you can change your mind more often than you change your socks! With digital cameras, you can experiment in real-time, crafting your black and white images on the fly. It’s all about developing that keen eye for B&W, seeing the world through a different lens, if you will. 

If you’re always shooting in color and only seeing the B&W version at home, you might find yourself in a creative labyrinth. Sure, practice makes perfect, but the fastest route to mastering B&W is to capture it in-camera. And if your camera has an electronic viewfinder (EVF)? Well, congratulations! You’re in for an even quicker ride to B&W brilliance. 

Now, let’s address the elephant in the room: shooting digital means your camera is capturing color, even when you’re previewing B&W. Fun, right? So if you want a truly solid B&W image, you might find yourself reaching for JPEG instead of RAW. But fear not! You can have your cake and eat it too, most modern cameras let you capture both formats simultaneously. Simply set your camera to RAW and follow along…

Person working on laptop in outdoor setting.

Setting up to shoot black and white is a piece of cake. With just a little understanding of filters, you can express yourself creatively without lugging around a bag full of them. Digital B&W offers unparalleled convenience.

For my Nikon friends (and really, for anyone with a digital camera), it’s as easy as pie! Just navigate to the Shooting Menu, select “Set Picture Control,” and voilà, choose “Monochrome.” From there, you’ll be greeted with an array of options like Sharpening, Contrast, Brightness, Filter Effects, and Toning. Sounds fancy, right? But don’t fret; it’s simple.

The filters? They’re just there to lighten specific tones and darken their opposites on the color wheel. For outdoor portraits, a red filter will brighten skin tones while deepening those skies. And let’s be honest: who doesn’t want a little more drama in their shots?

There are plenty of reasons to embrace shooting B&W in-camera. It’s not just easy to set up, but it also allows you to experiment without the hassle of carrying around physical filters. Plus, if things don’t turn out as planned, you can always drop that RAW shot into Lightroom, and use my black and white AI Profile for Imagen. B&W perfection in an instant.

So, whether you choose to shoot in B&W or convert later, remember that it’s all about what works for you and your artistic vision. Now, go forth and create some stunning black and white masterpieces!

Couple smiling, color and black-and-white split effect.

Hypersensitive Panchromatic

This isn’t just another preset. It’s a finely tuned AI-driven editing profile created from the analysis of over 10,000 of my personal black & white photo edits. The result? You get instant access to the clean, film-inspired look with the perfect contrast between tones that I provide to my own clients. Now available to you at the click of a button.

Lenses and Lyrics podcast
Hypersensitive panchromatic film container

Step Into

The Dojo

📖 Sign up and join the thousands of other photographers on your journey to success. be the first to know about fresh content, special offers and so much more.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
What's your name?

Comments

20 responses to “To Photograph in B&W or Convert in Post? The Great Debate!”

  1. I found this article to be incredibly enlightening. The way it breaks down the process of shooting in black and white versus converting later is both informative and engaging. It made me realize that there’s no one-size-fits-all answer to this question, which is refreshing. It’s all about personal preference and what helps each artist express their vision best. I appreciate the humor sprinkled throughout, making a potentially dry topic much more enjoyable to read.

  2. Scarlett

    Honestly, I think this discussion misses the point entirely. Why do we need to overthink something as straightforward as photography? Just take your pictures however you want and stop worrying about whether it should be black and white or color. The artistic debate seems forced here, almost like trying to make something out of nothing. At the end of the day, it’s just photography, not rocket science.

    1. Benjamin

      It seems like you’re dismissing an important aspect of photography by calling it straightforward. Every choice made in art reflects personal style and intention. Engaging in these discussions can actually help photographers grow and refine their craft.

    2. Eulalie Avatar

      I agree with Scarlett to some extent; sometimes the simplest approach yields the best results! While technique matters, creativity should remain fun rather than a chore filled with endless rules.

  3. This article feels like a comedy sketch more than an informative piece on photography techniques! The comparisons are amusing and make for light reading but left me wondering if there’s any real depth to the advice being shared. I mean, how many times can one mention filters or ‘seeing in tones’? It’s almost like they were reaching for things to say while trying not to get too serious about such a subjective topic.

    1. ‘Comedy sketch’ is spot on! The whole thing reads like an exaggerated tutorial trying too hard to be clever instead of simply presenting useful information clearly and concisely.

    2. ‘Seeing in tones’ sounds profound until you realize it’s just another way of saying ‘look at stuff differently.’ I guess that’s what makes art subjective—everyone has their own interpretation! But let’s be honest; sometimes less is more when explaining these concepts.

  4. ‘Should I shoot in B&W or convert later?’ That’s like asking if I should wear socks with sandals—there’s no clear answer! Just like styles in fashion, it all comes down to personal taste and what feels right at the moment.

  5. This post seems to trivialize an important aspect of photography. Choosing to shoot in black and white requires a thoughtful approach that isn’t captured by jokes about pizza toppings. Not everyone has the luxury of experimenting freely.

    1. Amelia, I think you’re missing the point. The humor is meant to make readers feel more relaxed about their choices rather than diminish their significance. It encourages exploration!

  6. I absolutely loved this article! It perfectly captures the essence of artistic expression in photography. The comparison of shooting in black and white versus color is so relatable, and I appreciated the humor throughout. It’s refreshing to see such a light-hearted take on a topic that often feels overly serious.

    1. I completely agree with you, Freya! The humor really makes the subject more approachable. Photography should be fun, and this article encourages creativity without strict rules.

    2. While I see your point, I think the author oversimplifies a complex decision for photographers. The choice between shooting in black and white or color can have significant implications for composition and mood.

  7. Honestly, I think the entire debate over whether to shoot in black and white or convert later is overhyped. Each approach has its merits, but I’ve seen plenty of stunning images produced both ways. What matters is the final result, not the method used to get there.

  8. While I appreciate the enthusiasm behind this topic, I feel like it undermines the value of color photography. Black and white has its place, but dismissing color as merely a distraction seems a bit narrow-minded. Art should embrace all forms.

    1. ‘Narrow-minded’ is an interesting choice of words here. Color photography definitely has its merits, but it’s not about dismissing one for the other; it’s about exploring different avenues of creativity.

  9. I love how you captured the essence of being a photographer! It’s all about creativity and personal vision. Shooting in black and white can be so liberating, especially when you start seeing the world through that lens! Thank you for sharing your insights.

  10. I found this article to be quite enlightening. The way you broke down the pros and cons of shooting in black and white versus color really resonated with me. I appreciate your encouragement for photographers to find their own unique style instead of sticking to rigid rules. It’s a refreshing perspective that I will keep in mind for my future projects.

  11. ‘Should’ and ‘never’ are indeed tricky words in art! As someone who often shoots both color and black and white, I’ve learned that flexibility leads to better artistry. The post does a great job highlighting this point!

  12. ‘Experimentation’ is what photography is all about! Capturing images in black and white can lead to some truly magical results if done right. Your enthusiasm is contagious; it makes me want to grab my camera now!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Listen on Apple Podcasts
Listen on Spotify