FB Pixel

Why Facebook Groups Beat Other Platforms for Communities

A community of photographers sitting in a room with a Facebook advertisement on the wall

In today’s digital age, the importance of fostering online communities has never been greater. Whether for a hobby, business, or support group, finding the right platform to host your community can make a difference. Among the myriad of choices available, Facebook Groups have consistently stood out as a strong contender. In this article, I’ll dive into why Facebook Groups might beat other platforms for building and growing your online community.

Introduction

When it comes to online communities, it’s essential to choose a platform that offers both functionality and ease of use. With its enormous user base and integrated ecosystem, Facebook provides a compelling choice through its Groups feature. These groups can be tailored to suit any interest, making it easy for users to find and engage with like-minded individuals.

Facebook Groups are more than just a place to share posts and comments. They offer a variety of tools to facilitate meaningful interaction, like events, polls, and file sharing. With Facebook Live, group members can even host live sessions, bringing real-time engagement to the table. The sheer versatility of Facebook Groups makes it a persuasive option that caters to a wide array of needs.

Beyond the tools and features, Facebook Groups excel in one key area: accessibility. Almost everyone has a Facebook account, and the platform’s ubiquity ensures that members can easily join and participate without any additional sign-ups or learning curves. This ease of access can significantly boost member participation and retention, setting Facebook Groups apart from other platforms.

Why you’re told to move your community away from Facebook

Despite the many advantages of Facebook Groups, you’ll often hear advice suggesting that you move your community to a different platform. One common reason is data privacy concerns. Facebook has had its fair share of controversies surrounding data breaches and misuse, prompting many to seek safer community hosting alternatives.

Another factor is Facebook’s algorithm-driven nature. Posts within groups are subject to Facebook’s algorithms, sometimes resulting in members missing important updates. This lack of control over what gets seen and what doesn’t can frustrate community managers trying to ensure consistent engagement and information dissemination.

Then, there are data, analytics, and insights. Facebook Groups provide some data for you to work with, but it’s not nearly as flexible or detailed as alternative community platforms.

Lastly, there’s the issue of branding and ownership. On Facebook, you are essentially building your community on rented land. You don’t have full control over your group’s design, layout, or even how it appears in searches. These limitations can be a significant drawback for those who want a more personalized and branded experience.

An example of this is Facebook removing Rooms, their internal Google Meet or Zoom feature exclusive to Groups.

A community of photographers sitting in a room with a Facebook advertisement on the wall

Alternative and dedicated community platforms

Given these concerns, many turn to dedicated community platforms like Discord, Slack, or even solutions like Circle, Skool, and Mighty Networks. These platforms offer greater control over data, branding, and user experience, making them attractive alternatives to Facebook Groups.

Discord, for instance, is popular among gamers but has expanded its reach into various niches. It provides robust voice, text, and video communication features within private servers that give admins control over their community environment. Slack, originally designed for workplace collaboration, has also become a versatile tool for community building, offering integrations with tons of external apps to enhance functionality.

Then there’s Mighty Networks and Cricle, platforms specifically designed for community building. They offer features like customizable member profiles, detailed analytics, and premium subscription options, making it an excellent choice for those looking to monetize their community. These platforms provide a more controlled and often more professional environment for community interaction, addressing many of the limitations of Facebook Groups.

A community of photographers sitting in a room with a Facebook advertisement on the wall

Why I decided to stick with a Facebook Group

Despite these limitations and the attractiveness of alternative options, I ultimately decided to stick with a Facebook Group for the Imagen Community, and here’s why. First and foremost, the sheer number of photographers on Facebook ensures that the group has a large potential audience. This makes it easier for me to grow the community organically and reach people who might not be aware of other platforms.

Another reason is Facebook’s integrated ecosystem. From event organization to real-time chat via Messenger, having all these features under one roof simplifies management and enhances user engagement. The convenience of having everything in one place outweighs the limitations for many community leaders, including myself.

Sure, the event system has its flaws and sometimes doesn’t remind people of events they RSVP’d to, and the removed Rooms features make live conversations more complicated. But at the end of the day, photographers are there.

Lastly, Facebook’s user-friendly interface on desktop and mobile and familiarity are hard to beat. Almost everyone knows how to navigate Facebook, so new members have little to no learning curve. This ease of use encourages participation and helps maintain a vibrant, active community, ultimately the most important aspect.

The ultimate deciding factor

I was 99% sure I would move the Imagen Community off of Facebook until something extremely interesting happened multiple times.

I noticed a handful of businesses in the photography industry, including one of the largest photography tradeshows, attempt to move their communities to private platforms: Circle, Mighty Networks, and Heartbeat.

What happened did not surprise me, but it still blew my mind.

The groups, which had thousands of photographers, only had a couple hundred move to their dedicated community platforms, which also meant low reach and engagement at a high cost.

So those communities shut down, and all but 1 moved back to Facebook. The last moved to Instagram (which, by the way, does not have a community feature).

Conclusion

In conclusion, while Facebook Groups have limitations and face stiff competition from dedicated community platforms, their accessibility, integrated features, and massive user base make them a compelling choice for many community leaders.

The ability to tap into a vast network of users and leverage Facebook’s versatile tools often outweighs the downsides. Whether starting a new community or considering a platform switch, it’s crucial to carefully weigh the pros and cons to decide what’s best for your needs. At the end of the day, the goal is to create a vibrant, engaged community, and for many, Facebook Groups remain the best place to do just that.

Don’t shut out Facebook Groups solely because it’s not the best community platform.

Figure out where your audience is, and that is where you need to be—even with better software solutions available for your community.

Share this with friends:

Join the Community

Sign up and join the thousands of other photographers on your journey to success. be the first to know about fresh content, special offers and so much more.

What's your name?
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.


The Workflows Photography Podcast

Workflows is a photography podcast about saving you time and money in your photography business. Tune in to hear stories, strategies, and tools that can be your rock.

Photo Breakdown Podcast cover image

Ever wondered what photographers really think about the latest gear, trends, and the stories behind their favorite shots? Photo Breakdown takes you behind the lens and into the minds of today’s top photographers, offering bite-sized episodes packed with insider insights, gear debates, and industry buzz.

Comments

20 responses to “Why Facebook Groups Beat Other Platforms for Communities”

  1. ThoughtfulMind Avatar
    ThoughtfulMind

    I appreciate the balanced perspective here. While data privacy is a real concern, the sheer convenience and user base of Facebook Groups make them a viable option. Excellent points made throughout the piece!

  2. InsightfulReader Avatar
    InsightfulReader

    This article provides a compelling argument for sticking with Facebook Groups despite the allure of alternative platforms. The ease of access and integrated ecosystem you mentioned are indeed hard to beat. Great read!

  3. CriticalThinker Avatar
    CriticalThinker

    The discussion on Facebook’s integrated features like events and Messenger is spot on. These tools provide a seamless experience for community management. Your insights are very valuable. Thank you for sharing!

  4. EngagedUser Avatar
    EngagedUser

    The personal accounts of other photography communities failing to transition away from Facebook add a very practical dimension to your argument. It’s clear that Facebook Groups present unique advantages worth considering. Great article!

  5. Jodie27 Avatar

    Yeah, I’m sure Facebook’s ‘user-friendly interface’ will really compensate for those missing notifications and vanished Rooms. But who needs important updates when you’ve got Messenger?

  6. CuriousObserver Avatar
    CuriousObserver

    Your experience with other communities moving back to Facebook due to low engagement on alternative platforms is eye-opening. It underscores the importance of meeting your audience where they are. Well done!

  7. Jayden94 Avatar
    Jayden94

    ‘The ultimate deciding factor’? Sounds like Facebook won because no one wanted to pay for something better. Guess we’re all just stuck in the Zuckerberg zone now!

  8. Jake Kelly Avatar
    Jake Kelly

    Nunca pensé en todas las herramientas que ofrece Facebook Groups. Parece una opción interesante.

  9. Francesca Kennedy Avatar
    Francesca Kennedy

    Es cierto que casi todos tienen cuenta en Facebook, eso facilita las cosas para unirse a un grupo.

  10. Martin Simpson Avatar
    Martin Simpson

    Me preocupa un poco lo de la privacidad de datos, pero parece que Facebook Groups tiene muchas ventajas.

  11. Davis Samuel Avatar
    Davis Samuel

    Facebook groupz are the best!! It’s so easy for everyone to use and find people wo like the same stuff. I dont think I would go anywhere else!

  12. Aaron Miller Avatar
    Aaron Miller

    Yea, Facebook is just so big and every1’s on it. I love how simple it is and all the tools like events and live. Really makes connecting easy.

  13. Rphillips Avatar
    Rphillips

    I think fb group is great becuz everyone already has facebook… makes it so much easier for folks to join. I like the tools too like polls and events.

  14. Ruth Morris Avatar
    Ruth Morris

    I don’t mind Facebook’s algoritms. I think it’s just fun to see the posts and the live videos. Facebook groups works fine for me! ????

  15. Igriffiths Avatar
    Igriffiths

    Facebook groups are good because its popular and lots of people know how to use it. Those other platforms sound confusing.

  16. Isobel55 Avatar

    Oh great, another love letter to Facebook. Because, you know, nothing screams ‘privacy’ like a platform known for data breaches. But hey, at least it’s ‘convenient,’ right?

  17. Ava Summers Avatar
    Ava Summers

    Your perspective adds significant value—well done!

  18. I disagree that Facebook Groups are the best option. It’s too easy for people to miss important posts because of how Facebook works with its algorithms. Plus, it’s true that it’s not safe with all these data privacy concerns. I’d prefer something where I can control who sees what without these problems!

  19. Chapman Caitlin Avatar
    Chapman Caitlin

    I don’t think Facebook Groups are that good. Yes, many people have Facebook, but the privacy issues are a real problem. Also, with the algorithm hiding posts, you can’t really trust that members will see important updates. Other platforms like Discord are better because you have more control over everything.

  20. Kelly Ruth Avatar

    I understand why you stick to Facebook Groups, but honestly, I feel like other platforms give more freedom. With Facebook, you’re limited in design and control. I would rather build a community on something like Mighty Networks where I can customize everything and not worry about the algorithm messing things up.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *